In Tamil cinema, a severe step by step process is the key to romantic success. The hero of romantic films follows this process. This format defies all the social and evolutionary laws discovered by various scientists over the course of time. Most romantic films start off with the hero not having a job(or a life). We are also showed that this hero is needy and incapable of being assertive and taking control of his life if he has one, that is. This is portrayed through the various scenes present in the first quarter of the film. He has a best friend who is the proof for “There is somebody needier than me”. Then one day our needy hero is blown away by the beauty of the heroine whom he, in most films, sees at the bus stand or at some crowded signal. The wind god is very gracious and kind to our needy little friend. He blows the wind in two directions, on the face of the heroine and on the hero’s face(even though they are standing at opposite directions). As the relationship moves forward the hero executes his plan to get friend zoned(the funny part is he thinks he does not have a plan and that love and attraction works only when you go with the flow but, what he does not know is that he has the best plan. The plan that never fails at making new friends). The hero begs. He sings amazingly written songs. He buys her romantic gifts that cost more than the budget of the film(he still does not have a job at this point in the film). He goes behind her very ambitiously thinking she will fall for his ‘charm’. Nothing works. These films are pretty realistic taking into account the fact that the girl does not fall for him. All is well until this point where a song plays(colours and slow motion in the songs are more than needed) and everything changes. Everything is falling towards the Earth just like Newton said it would and one day someone plays a song and everything suddenly starts flying up.
One director who did not defy these laws and etched characters that were irresistible to women is Mani Ratnam. He has proven himself by writing heart-throbs. Heart-throbbing characters in films such as Ayidha Ezhuthu, Mouna Raagam, Agni Natchathiram. These characters are unpredictable, fun and they know what they need to do with their lives. They have purpose and drive. This excites the girls. Mani Ratnam makes the woman follow the man(sorry feminists). This is contradictory to the format of Tamil romance movies and thus, a more realistic happy-ending film is obtained.
Mani Ratnam makes complete films, that is, the screenplay, cinematography, dialogues and the story put together tells a tale and never fails to satisfy you. There are movies where the screenplay is king. There are movies where the story is king. Most directors make films from one aspect of filmaking, that is, the screenplay, story, dialogues, etc. They put in all their effort and sweat into making one thing entertain and tell the tale. Mani Ratnam is unlike these filmmakers. He does not make films that have two or three individual components that satisfy you. He make the film tell you the story and not just one individual aspect. This was true until he made Kaatru Veliyidai.
Mani Ratnam has attempted to write a movie and story that is built upon his protagonist but he forgot that in order to do that not only do he need a movie but he also needed a story. I tried hard to find the story and point of this film but, simply failed miserably every time I tried. The man in the lead is Karthi whose name is Varun in the movie. Varun is self-centered. This according to every character in the film is the problem with Varun. Every time Varun smiles one character jumps out to say “nee unnoda santhoshatha pathi mattum dhaan yosikura…”. You can make a point and then move on with the film but, Mani Ratnam twists this, he made a film and them moved on with the point. What is the problem with a self-centered guy? If he was truly self-centered and did nothing for anyone else but himself he would not have any friends or family.
This film has one thing that it completely depended upon, the protagonist, Varun. Mani Ratnam after writing wonderful characters such as Manohar from Mouna Ragam and Michael from Ayidha Ezhuthu has run out of substance to base his new character Varun on. All Mani Ratnam knew when he wrote his Kaatru Valiyidai was that he needs an ‘attractive guy’ to base his film on and thankfully, just like me he was smart enough to know that the usual the Tamil hero is not the typical attractive male that females find tempting so he decided to steal from Hollywood instead.
The whole theme of aircraft, the uniform, the concept of doctor(who is superior to Varun given Varun’s position in the airforce just like Charlotte is Maverick’s teacher in Top gun) and the air force pilot love story, the character and Varun’s best friend dying was ‘inspired’ from Top Gun. Inspired to such an extent that he has stolen the whole thing! Everything!
The conflict that this film puts forth is interesting. Kaatru Veliyidai tells the story of how women will fall in love with a guy, however, self-absorbed, selfish and egoistic he is. In fact, this gives them a flurry of emotions both negative and positive. There have been rockstars who will beat up their gorgeous female sex partners to the pulp and yet, she would not go away. Interesting. Mani Ratnam has ventured into the complex land of mating. Men who are driven by purpose and how nothing fazes them out(including women) are among the key factors in Ratnam’s romantic male characters. They are ships and the women are like waves. Waves never topple the ship and the ship keeps moving forward. This concept is portrayed beautifully in many movies such as Streetcar Named Desire, Top Gun, Mouna Ragam, Agni Natchathiram, Kaaka Kaaka, The Wild one and Gone with the Wind. This film with amazing potential(due to this intriguing emotional conflict in the world of romance) does not fail to disappoint. In order to make this conflict succeed Mani Ratnam needs an effective, attractive and powerful protagonist and thus he has merrily taken various aspects of the characters of the movies mentioned above and has come up with Varun.
When I was young my mum used to tell me that I must finish one task fully before I go to the next. I am almost certain Mani Ratnam was not told that he had to finish one thing before he moved on to the next. This painful childhood negligence has resulted in Varun’s character. Very evidently this is what happened. Mani Ratnam was stealing from Top Gun. He found it boring after a point and started stealing from Stanley’s character from Streetcar Named Desire. We can see this when Varun makes up for his fight with his girl just as Stanley does in Streetcar Named Desire. The problem here is that this does not fit the character that Varun has established before the making up scene occurs. When he got bored with that he moved on to The Wild One. Suddenly they start digging up the wall which is again inspired from The Shawshank Redemption. He has not even stolen properly. The reason is as follows.
When you want to make an adventurous character you do not steal from both James Bond and Indiana Jones for the mere reason that both of them are very adventurous. These two characters have plenty of differences and yet both of them are adventurous. While looking for inspiration for Kaatru Veliyidai, instead of googling ‘Adventurous movie characters’ Mani Ratnam googled ‘Attractive male movie characters’. Mani Ratnam has made a character out of many attractive characters that have shaken cinema over the years. This does not work for the simple reason that Varun’s character(on whose character the whole film depends on) is inconsistent. You cannot afford to make a character this inconsistent and not coherent at all when the film depends on the character.
The movie is held up by two more key factors. Music and Cinematography. The music in this film is very unique and blends in very well with the scenes and does not awkwardly stand out. A. R Rahman has composed Tango, Folk and other unique genres. I am not very sound in the area of music and hence, I am going to stop right there.
The cinematography has elevated the movie and has shown us shots from different perspectives. For example, when we see the aeroplanes flying and there is sexual tension inside the vehicle we do not see the scenery and the beauty of the landscape on the outside instead we see what we need to see, the relationship between Varun and Leela. This, in my opinion, is amazing. This does not mean that the cinematographer has failed to capture the beauty of the snow and mountains. He has excelled in the task given to him and we see breathtaking visuals composed of not only the already awe-inspiring mountains but of normal things. One example where just the music and cinematography have elevated this film is during the escape towards the end of the film. The chase has dust and sand flying around with an old truck that looks like it will break down any second flying at huge speeds amidst the man-made mud storm. This is captured brilliantly and the background score compliments this scene.
Overall, Kaatru Veliyidai has a very interesting concept and conflict. It has shown different aspects and problems in the relationship between the driven man and a woman. The conflict between us and the movie arises when Varun’s character tries to cover all the aspects of the man’s side of the relationship which is not possible because everybody and every character is not the same. There is obviously more than one attractive man and these men may be and will be very different. One cannot insert all the traits of all attractive men into one character. If done so the character shall be very inconsistent and incoherent. This is an absolute character based film with not much of a story(which does not matter as long as the character is strong and consistent enough) but a beautiful conflict. The music and the cinematography are brilliant and the sum of the music and cinematography is greater than the whole. One must watch this movie to understand the conflict but as a film, Kaatru Veliyidai disappoints me.
2.5/5